In the world of Toronto real estate, love doesn’t always bloom over granite countertops or walk-in closets. Sometimes, it’s the unexpected—a vintage rotary phone built into the wall or a backyard gnome village—that seals the deal. At Toste & Co, we’ve seen our fair share of swoon-worthy surprises.
Here’s a lighthearted look at the quirks that made buyers say, “This is the one!”
1. The Retro Pink Bathroom That Sparked Joy
A 1950s bungalow in East York had been on the market for weeks—until one couple walked in and fell for its bubblegum-pink tub, matching sink, and floral tile. “It reminded me of my grandmother’s house,” the buyer said. Nostalgia won over modernity.
2. The Secret Bookshelf Door in Roncesvalles
Behind a floor-to-ceiling bookshelf in a semi-detached home was a hidden office—complete with a speakeasy-style light fixture. The buyer, a mystery novelist, called it “the plot twist I didn’t know I needed.”
3. Urban Chicken Coop in Leslieville
Yes, it was legal. Yes, it was adorable. A small coop with two hens named Maple and Mocha became the deciding factor for a young family seeking a sustainable lifestyle. Bonus: fresh eggs and a built-in lesson in responsibility for the kids.
4. Basement Arcade in Scarborough
A fully functional 1980s-style arcade—Pac-Man, pinball, and all—turned a dated basement into a retro paradise. The buyer, a tech entrepreneur, called it “the ultimate stress reliever.”
5. Indoor Jungle in The Annex
A sunroom converted into a lush indoor greenhouse, complete with a koi pond and hanging ferns, captivated a couple who had just returned from Costa Rica. “It felt like a vacation every day,” they said.
6. Vintage Sewing Nook in a Junction Triangle Loft
A built-in sewing station with antique drawers and a fold-out table was the clincher for a fashion designer. “It was like the home was waiting for me,” she said.
7. Catwalks and Climbing Walls in a Cabbagetown Victorian
Designed for feline royalty, this home featured custom catwalks, tunnels, and a “catio” (cat patio). The buyer? A proud cat dad with three rescue tabbies.
Love Is in the (Real Estate) Details
While square footage and location matter, it’s often the quirky, personal touches that turn a house into the home.
At Toste & Co, we celebrate the charm, character, and unexpected features that make Toronto real estate unforgettable. Whether it’s a pink bathroom or a secret door, we’re here to help you find your perfect match.
